PDA

View Full Version : Day 62 Alliance Analysis - Simming vs Raiding



Beetroot.
18 Dec 2016, 12:59 PM
Hello,

I think it's about time for another analysis as I am sure we are about to run out of names to guess :)

Let's see who is growing and developing best in each quad....

This is an analysis of simming and raiding! (Raiding taken from this week)

North East

Simming


# Players
Alliance/ confed
#Top20 Players
%Top20 Players
#Top50 Players
%Top50 Players
#Top100 Players
%Top 100 Players


60
AA
11
18%
23
38%
35
58%


42
C.S
0
0%
0
0%
1
2%



Raiding


#Players
Alliance/ confed
Total Raiding
#Top10 Raiders
Res Raided by Top10s
Raided By Rest of Alliance
Raiding per Player
Raiding Per Player -Top10


60
AA
16,799,213
2
4,295,652
12,503,561
279,987
215,579


42
C.S
3,822,665
1
1,261,021
2,561,644
91,016
62,479




Conclusion

AA are superb at Simming and Raiding - no real competition in quad!

North West

Simming


# Players
Alliance/ confed
#Top20 Players
%Top20 Players
#Top50 Players
%Top50 Players
#Top100 Players
%Top 100 Players


85
OLYMPIA + Pantheon
5
6%
10
12%
21
25%


76
NemRis + NemRis2
1
1%
3
4%
9
12%



Raiding


#Players
Alliance/ confed
Total Raiding
#Top10 Raiders
Res Raided by Top10s
Raided By Rest of Alliance
Raiding per Player
Raiding Per Player -Top10


85
OLYMPIA + Pantheon
20,837,713
5
14,201,144
6,636,569
245,150
82,957


76
NemRis + NemRis2
2,979,064
0
0
2,979,064
39,398
39,398



Conclusion

Olympia and Pantheon are very much in control of their quad.. Progressing well on both fronts, the only negative is the raiding per player when you take away the top 5 raiders..

South West

Simming



# Players
Alliance/ confed
#Top20 Players
%Top20 Players
#Top50 Players
%Top50 Players
#Top100 Players
%Top 100 Players


91
SWM + S.C
1
1%
3
3%
7
8%


85
OCG + OCG1
1
1%
4
5%
11
13%



Raiding



#Players
Alliance/ confed
Total Raiding
#Top10 Raiders
Res Raided by Top10s
Raided By Rest of Alliance
Raiding per Player
Raiding Per Player -Top10


91
SWM + S.C
8,110,030
0
0
8,110,030
89,121
89,121


85
OCG + OCG1
6,056,813
0
0
6,056,813
71,257
71,257



Conclusion

This quad is crazy.. Both are terrible at raiding and simming, NemRis seem to be growing faster and SWM seem to be raiding more. SWM are ahead here purely because S.C are making the stats lower.

Can they stop bashing the crap out of each other to make some actual growth?? Who knows...

South East

Simming


# Players
Alliance/ confed
#Top20 Players
%Top20 Players
#Top50 Players
%Top50 Players
#Top100 Players
%Top 100 Players


76
LCA + LCA2
0
0%
3
4%
12
16%



Raiding


#Players
Alliance/ confed
Total Raiding
#Top10 Raiders
Res Raided by Top10s
Raided By Rest of Alliance
Raiding per Player
Raiding Per Player -Top10


76
LCA + LCA2
9,860,992
2
3,891,829
5,969,163
129,750
80,664



Conclusion

No competition here, LCA are growing and raiding reasonably well

Final Thoughts..

1st - AA are simming miles better than anyone else, and have better raiding averages.. They are the servers clear favourites today!

2nd - Olympia/ Pantheon are probably second. They have some competition in their quad but steadily growing and raiding.

3rd - LCA are here. I would expect their raiding and simming stats to be higher as they sat alone doing not much of anything ... time will tell..

4th - SWM probably make it in as forth but they may have to stop bashing the crap out of OCG if they want a real chance at the server :)

Let me know if you agree with the results!!

Enjoy

Beetnik

antonio
18 Dec 2016, 01:40 PM
I agree with you thoughts with regard to simming. Maybe I should take the blame here for my direction towards troops. i make simming a dirty word Great effort.

ggnore13
18 Dec 2016, 07:41 PM
Yey! Analysis! Thank you for the time and effort you put into it :ahoy: As for the results I'll have to agree with them. While I firmly believe simming is overrated AA results on the climbers chart are almost double that of the rest of the server and coupled with some very good raiding means they'll be a formidable opponent comes mid game.
As for SW - clearly the most interesting quad so far. Those fights will take their toll on both of the teams of course but sometimes you just spawn in a competitive quad and you have to deal with it or form meta and be hated by the rest of the server for it :D
LCA are the dark horse of the server. They are alone in their quad and it seems like they will have no natural enemy in the mid game so they will be presented lots of interesting diplomatic choices. If they run for a WW on their own the server might turn out with 4 WW quads which would be awesome.

The Zombie
18 Dec 2016, 10:20 PM
Yey! Analysis! Thank you for the time and effort you put into it :ahoy: As for the results I'll have to agree with them. While I firmly believe simming is overrated AA results on the climbers chart are almost double that of the rest of the server and coupled with some very good raiding means they'll be a formidable opponent comes mid game.
As for SW - clearly the most interesting quad so far. Those fights will take their toll on both of the teams of course but sometimes you just spawn in a competitive quad and you have to deal with it or form meta and be hated by the rest of the server for it :D
LCA are the dark horse of the server. They are alone in their quad and it seems like they will have no natural enemy in the mid game so they will be presented lots of interesting diplomatic choices. If they run for a WW on their own the server might turn out with 4 WW quads which would be awesome.

Something strange has just happened. I agree fully with everything my good friend ggnore just said.. I'm speechless now sorry can't say anymore. Need to lie down in a cold dark room and re-evaluate :D

Omega-Ro
18 Dec 2016, 11:37 PM
Nice job.

FREYA
19 Dec 2016, 07:15 AM
I dont really agree with the analysis. Agree with raid points, but not agree with sims player.

Why? because you only put top 20 player. meanwhile i believe the server winner is usually ally with the most top 100 player.

Top player does`t mean they have stabilize condition, for server normal, stabilize growth more important than attack point and etc. This is marathon not sprint contest.

for that i believe LCA is at no.4, SWM and OGC is at no.3.

Beetroot.
19 Dec 2016, 07:41 AM
I dont really agree with the analysis. Agree with raid points, but not agree with sims player.

Why? because you only put top 20 player. meanwhile i believe the server winner is usually ally with the most top 100 player.


Interesting points about OCG,

but FYI, I did do the simming stats up to top 100 :)
OGC had 11 players out of 85 in the top 100
SWM had 7 players out of 91 in the top 100

Not a lot really

ggnore13
19 Dec 2016, 08:48 AM
Something strange has just happened. I agree fully with everything my good friend ggnore just said.. I'm speechless now sorry can't say anymore. Need to lie down in a cold dark room and re-evaluate :D

Yeah.. I myself was quite surprised while I was writing my post.. I didn't even tried to trashtalk the conclusion of AA being named the today's favorites. I think the Christmas spirit has gotten into me :D

Hawkery
19 Dec 2016, 03:21 PM
Yey! Analysis! Thank you for the time and effort you put into it :ahoy: As for the results I'll have to agree with them. While I firmly believe simming is overrated AA results on the climbers chart are almost double that of the rest of the server and coupled with some very good raiding means they'll be a formidable opponent comes mid game.
As for SW - clearly the most interesting quad so far. Those fights will take their toll on both of the teams of course but sometimes you just spawn in a competitive quad and you have to deal with it or form meta and be hated by the rest of the server for it :D
LCA are the dark horse of the server. They are alone in their quad and it seems like they will have no natural enemy in the mid game so they will be presented lots of interesting diplomatic choices. If they run for a WW on their own the server might turn out with 4 WW quads which would be awesome.

I'd also agree. AA have certainly taken the server by storm and this will no doubt continue to grow as time goes on.

As for the SW I think it's the only quad to be engaged in constant combat. Some players moan raiding is too easy (you know who you are) or that the server is boring. It's because SWM's heavyweights are otherwise occupied :p

I'd also agree with you on LCA too. Having played with them before I know they have the capacity and potential to win, though in recent servers they seem to have lost their fighting spirit. They are also very predictable, though it lends the dark horse analogy the potential to be so much darker.

I reckon we're either in for one of the most interesting servers, or everyone will flop and it'll turn out to be one of the most boring. No middle ground for 2017 ;)

FREYA
20 Dec 2016, 04:24 AM
Interesting points about OCG,

but FYI, I did do the simming stats up to top 100 :)
OGC had 11 players out of 85 in the top 100
SWM had 7 players out of 91 in the top 100

Not a lot really

and from LC only 9 player at top 100, LC is representative from quad SE, and i will automatically give explanation SE is the weakest quad now, only 9 id comparing with other quad, event from SW the crowded quad.

There is no debating now that AA is the strongest ally in this server, their gold power so amazing 8)

Eric Rasputin
22 Dec 2016, 09:40 AM
There is no debating now that AA is the strongest ally in this server, their gold power so amazing 8)

Andy has some fans now :P

- - - Updated - - -


I'd also agree with you on LCA too. Having played with them before I know they have the capacity and potential to win, though in recent servers they seem to have lost their fighting spirit. They are also very predictable, though it lends the dark horse analogy the potential to be so much darker.

:Popcorn:

The Zombie
23 Dec 2016, 12:39 PM
I always like to collect a few new fans along the way Eric :D

Looking forward to a nice Christmas then 6 months of no sleep and stresses, haha

Merry Christmas Everyone, looking forward to the next analysis after the arties :)

Andy

thedevilexists
06 Mar 2017, 01:52 PM
Been away from this game for like 4 years but one thing that wont ever change SWM fail lol